Every site reviewed on Legitimate Online Casinos goes through the same five stages. Nothing is ranked from a press release and no operator sees a review before it publishes.
I find the operating company and licence in the terms and footer, then check that the licensee named on the regulator's register matches the entity in the agreement. A badge image counts for nothing. A mismatch between the licence and the terms is an automatic fail, and it removed sites I had otherwise been ready to include.
I look at when and how the site verifies identity. Proportionate checks — ID and proof of address, requested up front — pass. Documents demanded for the first time only after a withdrawal, or intrusive questions about employment and source of funds with no clear reason, fail. Genuine compliance happens at onboarding, not as a stalling tactic at the cashier.
I fund every site with my own money, between $50 and $250, using the rails a US player actually has — Visa, Mastercard, Bitcoin, Litecoin, USDT. A method advertised on the banking page that declines three times in a row goes in the notes. A cashier that cannot reliably take money will not reliably return it.
I request a withdrawal and time it from submission to funds landing, recording what verification asked for, whether the request was reversed, and whether support could explain any delay in plain language. Reversal windows are logged separately, because a cancellable pending cashout is the most common way a payout quietly disappears back into play.
I read the agreement in full before writing — wagering multiples, maximum cashout caps, per-transaction and monthly limits, dormancy fees, and every clause that lets an operator void winnings. Then I check whether the published dispute route leads anywhere real, because a rulebook is only as good as the process for challenging it.
I search the operator's name alongside complaint and arbitration on the large independent player forums. I am not counting complaints — every operator has those — I am checking whether they get resolved and whether the operator shows up under its own name to answer them. Public accountability is the closest thing to a track record this market offers.
Reader reports about withdrawals are genuinely useful and get followed up. Corrections are made quickly and noted. Email info@legitimateonlinecasinos.com — it reaches Corinne directly rather than a support queue.